‘Passion, determination & commitment’ – an interview with Stephen Kelly

A mother holds her child in the courtyard of their home within the Qi Lihe district in Lanzhou city, Gansu Province, northwestern China. Copyright Stephen Kelly.

Stephen Kelly’s work came to my attention a couple of months ago when he dropped me an email. In particular, his work ‘Qi Lihe‘ that looks at Muslim minority groups in China’s industrial north stood out. It was obvious that this was not a project shot in a couple of weeks; Stephen likes to take his time. His website only features four major pieces of work, and one of those is still in progress. That methodical approach is fuelled by a deep interest in the social and political issues at work in the communities and situations he photographs. Below is an interview with Stephen (SK) for The Rights Exposure Project (REP) where he reveals a bit more about his methodology, motivations and aims.

***

REP: As a young photographer how have you adapted to the shrinking media space for photographic work?

SK: I am very independent when it comes to working on my personal projects and I haven’t changed the way I approach my working practice. The majority of my work is self-funded, so whatever money I make, usually goes straight back into working on my projects. I also apply for grants for certain projects in order to assist me financially in completing the work. Then I try to find different ways of showing and distributing the work; pushing the work to magazines to publish editorially or printing and presenting my work as an exhibition installation, which is a relatively new path I am only beginning to explore. I’ve also recently begun to run a number of workshops and I have found this to be incredibly rewarding whilst also being a solid way of being able to finance my upcoming projects.

A pole dancer performs to a small crowd of tourists inside the Greek Mythology casino in Taipa, Macau. Visa restrictions on mainland Chinese tourists are beginning to take it’s toll on the economy of Macau, as revenue growth is slowing for the first time in years. Copyright Stephen Kelly.

REP: Much of your work focuses on China (incl. Macau and Hong Kong). How easy has access been?

SK: Access has been difficult when working on a number of my projects. In Macau, my aim was to document the huge casino boom that has taken the region by storm. In order to do this, I felt that it was imperative that I photographed spontaneously inside the casinos. However, this is completely forbidden, so I had to be very patient, spending day after day wandering around, finding particular scenes that I knew I wanted to capture, returning time and time again until I got the image I was after and being very discreet with my approach. I had a few shady moments with security but generally I was able to make the images I needed with sensitivity and tact.

In Gansu Province when working on my ‘Qi Lihe’ series, I had a lot of problems with the police. I was working in the countryside attempting to document where the migrants had come from and why. The police interrogated me, followed me tirelessly and tried to stop me from doing my work. An example of this is when I visited a mosque one evening to make portraits of a group of Islamic students inside their dormitory. I knew one of the teachers, who I had met on a number of occasions and he had invited me to visit. While inside, the police rang the mosque’s office telephone and told the imam not to cooperate with me and warned him not to let me take any pictures. It became too difficult to work, knowing that the police were following my every move and were making it quite clear that they were going to stop me from trying to photograph.

A shepherd grazes his sheep on the hills above the Qi Lihe district. Although thousands of families have migrated into the city from their remote villages in the surrounding countryside, they still strive to hold onto their rural way of life. Copyright Stephen Kelly.

REP: What do you think are the pros and cons of foreign vs. local photographers? Is there a way to balance the outsider’s eye vs. the cultural reading of a local?

SK: Foreign and local photographers may approach their work in a different way and from a different angle. A local photographer will be more familiar with the setting and cultural environment, having always lived there but may also lack the broader perspective of an outsider looking in. They may also be restricted in their approach to a certain extent by limitations arising from their customs, religion and laws.

With my projects in China, I obviously have the eye of an outsider and this will never change when working in a foreign context. I believe you have to embrace this and strive to be honest, truthful and respectful when photographing and representing the people and places you are documenting.

The most important approach to take is to understand and appreciate the people and place I am documenting. I attempt to immerse myself within their environment, build relationships with the people I am photographing and try to understand their situation as much as is possible. I aim to stay for a prolonged period of time and return repeatedly, so even though I am a foreigner, I am able to culturally read their story to the best of my ability.

REP: Your latest work focuses on the Hui and Dongxiang Muslim minorities in Qi Lihe district in northwestern China. Can you tell us a bit about the origins of that project?

SK: This project came about due to information gained by a friend of mine who worked for Oxfam Hong Kong at the time. She told me about the situation of many internal Muslim migrant’s in Gansu Province who were arriving into the provincial capital, Lanzhou, as they were unable to survive anymore by living off their land in the countryside (in Linxia Hui Autonomous Prefecture). Extreme poverty and desertification forced their flight. My friend informed me that Oxfam Hong Kong were part-funding a school for the Muslim migrant children in the Qi Lihe district of Lanzhou. I was given the contact details of the headmistress of the school and shortly after that I was on a plane from Shenzhen to Lanzhou to research a possible project. I visited the school and began teaching English a few mornings a week and that is how my connection to this project began. One or two of the students would take me to visit their homes and meet their parents in the afternoon after teaching and then from there I would meet more families and return time and time again to strengthen my connection with and knowledge of the community.

REP: In the end you decided not to go back to Qi Lihe for the security of the people you were working with. What precautions do you take to try and protect those you photograph?

SK: It wasn’t that I decided not to go back. I did return in July 2012 but decided to leave early. I had planned to be there for one month but after two weeks it was just too difficult and I felt it was getting too dangerous, not only for myself but more importantly for the families I wanted to photograph and for my interpreter.

As for precautions, I followed the experience and intuition of my guide who is from Gansu and as soon as I knew that the police didn’t want me to be there and were following me and my guide felt it wasn’t safe to proceed, I stopped and left the province. The most important aspect for me is the safety of those who I photograph and for my guide and I didn’t want to take any risks or put anyone in danger.

A boy waits patiently for the lights to go out in one of the two communal dormitories in the centre. The boys follow a strict daily regime which begins at 6am when they are awoken and finishes at 10pm when the lights go out and they are locked in the rooms. Copyright Stephen Kelly.

REP: When you shoot a social piece like ‘Qi Lihe’ or ‘The Boys of Zheng Sheng‘ (youth rehabilitation centre on Lantau island, Hong Kong) how do you hope your work will contribute towards improving those peoples’ lives? Is it just a case of ‘getting their story out there’ or do you think there are other interventions that photographers can make with their work?

SK: In relation to these two projects, the most important aspect of my approach is to illustrate and highlight what is happening to these particular communities and why. I’m very much interested in documenting issues that are under-reported and by producing these bodies of work I hope to bring the stories of these people to a wider audience and shed light on communities living on the periphery of society. I aim to inform and bring a sense of awareness and understanding from the audience having viewed my work.

Awaiting order’s for the daily labouring. The centre is slowly expanding into the surrounding jungle and each day the boy’s are made to carry out particular building jobs including brickworking, plumbing, gardening and electrical networking. The staff at the centre believe it is good vocational training for when the boys re-enter Hong Kong society. Enabling them to apply for jobs, attempting to make a new life free from drugs and crime.

REP: Any tips for young photographers try to build a career?

SK: Have a strong passion, dedication and commitment to the issues that you are interested in exploring and documenting. Be determined, patient and find a way to complete the project even when faced with financial restraints. It’s important to continually make meaningful work and have a distinct voice and approach.

REP: What are you working on now?

SK: I’ve just begun working on a new project exploring Finland’s experiences with increasing migration flows to the country. I was in Helsinki for two weeks in November doing some research, making initial images and having meetings, so I’m looking forward to returning in the New Year and immersing myself in the project. I will also deliver a number of workshops in the coming months and will continue to work on commissions. If possible, I also plan to return to China later in the year.

WildAid, Chinese sports stars & shark fin soup

As series of short ads by WildAid featuring Chinese sports stars campaigning against the harvesting of shark fins.

 

 

 

Pollution from the textile industry in China – Greenpeace photos

Rather than climbing up stuff Qiu Bo went out and took some pics of the pollution caused by the textile industry in China (which probably includes the jeans your wearing).That’s for Greenpeace by the way.

Coca Cola’s subversive support for Tibetan independence?

I suspect this has more PSP than PLA but check out the International Campaign for Tibet’s blog on how this Coke ad may be secretly subversive.

Now did I ever tell you about my theory of how Disney’s ‘Lion King’ is Islamophobic…?

Chinese rabbit cartoon highlights social injustice

What has now become known as the ‘rabbit’ cartoon started doing the rounds at the weekend and is now going viral internationally. It watches a bit like an episode of South Park directed by Tarantino.

Depicting ordinary Chinese citizens as rabbits (we are about to enter the Year of the Rabbit) it shows them being abused by tigers (i.e. the Chinese government) in various ways linked to recent high profile scandals (including the tainted milk scandal) and everyday injustices (like forced evictions and impunity for those in power). It has apparently been censored in China, though the maker claims not to understand why.

What I said is true, and I don’t understand why they’re scared of cartoons,” said the video’s director, Wang Bo, who works with the Beijing-based animation studio Hutoon.

Cartoons are often the medium of choice for poking fun at  authoritarian power structures as can be seen in this post from last year highlighting the Green Dam Girl manga character mocking alleged plans by the Chinese government to have security software installed in all new computers. For more on how internet based satire is on the increase in China read this WSJ article. And for a comparison with the image the Chinese authorities would like to project internationally check this out.

China Village Documentary Project

From what I can gather this is part of an EU-China government project looking at the impact of ‘village self governance‘ reforms in rural China (grass-roots democracy). Basically, they went to 10 villages and gave 100 people either a stills camera or video camera and asked them to record the politics of the village. Now that has to be interesting!

The guy in the video is Jian Li, a film-maker interested in the changing social dynamics related to China’s fast-paced economic growth.

Apparently, one outcome was a documentary called ‘Seen & Heard‘ which was screened around the world. I can’t find it on-line so if anyone knows where a copy lurks please let me know.

Going naked on the internet

Kuang Biao’s cartoon made me smile. The caption translates as, ‘Take off your clothes. Now its your turn.’ This is making reference to the policy of citizens in China having to register using their real names, yet a total lack of transparency in government. The guy in the big coat with girls and cash stashed under it is supposed to be a government official.

For more on ‘running naked‘ on-line see the Global Voices feature on Zhang Lifan and his article, ‘Confessions of a naked internet runner.’ The Kafka-esque situation of ‘sensitive terms’ that are effectively banned on-line but not publicly acknowledged cannot help but evoke a dark political satire of authoritarianism. Maybe this is why some of the best political cartoonists have come from totalitarian regimes.

China censors beyond its borders – Drik exhibition on Tibet banned

If the Chinese government spouts one line consistently it is that other states should not interfere in its internal affairs. However, this obviously is a case of ‘do as I say not as I do‘. For at least the second time this year the Chinese government has tried to stop the showing of visual art that it did not like the the look of.

Drik Tibet_MG_1208

Copyright Drik

Today was supposed to be the opening of the exhibition ‘Into Exhile – Tibet 1949 – 2009′ held at the Drik photo-agency gallery in Dhaka, Bangladesh. However, as I write the gallery gate has been padlocked by the police and the gallery surrounded. The reason? “Going against the state.” Wow, not only were the Bangladesh authorities bowing to the Chinese government’s wishes but it sounds like the accepted their reason word for word too! Well, the guys at Drik are a resourceful bunch so are currently displaying the exhibition on the streets and online. However, if you go to the Drik News site you may get this warning;

Drik news site warning

Ignore it is my advice, I did and my laptop world has not ended (yet!). I wonder if those Chinese hackers are up to their old tricks again (see below)?

Things started to smell fishy when Shaidul Alam, founder and director of Drik, received a phone call from the Chinese embassy in Dhaka suggesting that the exhibition was not in everyone’s best interest. There was even mention of assisting Drik in regards to connections in China if the photos were never shown. The representative from the embassy obviously did not do his homework on either Shaidul or Drik. Such a phone call is the meat and drink of these guys. It is certainly not the first time they have faced such attempts at censorship. Undeterred, they kindly invited the embassy staff to come to the opening, say what they wanted, and even have their own exhibition at the gallery. Oddly enough they declined.

Then the other phone calls started to come. From various quarters they all had the same message, that the exhibition should not go ahead. All this culminated in Special Branch rocking up at the Drik gallery not long before the opening and locking the place down.

Drik opens exhibition on the streets in spite of pressure from t

Copyright Drik

The Chinese government’s increasing interference into other states is a worrying trend. Not satisfied with running their own complex censorship system they are attempting to make it transnational. These tactics work best on small countries such as Bangladesh, or Nepal where I am now, and smacks of bullying. So much for China the champion of the developing world. The Chinese government obviously thinks that it has jurisdiction over any content that relates to China where ever in the world it may be displayed. If pressure from the embassy does not work an unofficial cyber attack will be on its way. I guess it will not be long before the Chinese government lobbies to have ‘Green Dam Youth Escort‘ fitted on all PCs no matter where they are made.

The attempt to curtail freedom of expression in Bangladesh is not the first by the Chinese government this year. In July the Chinese authorities protested about the screening ‘10 Conditions of Love‘ a film about Rebiya Kadeer, leader of the World Uighur Congress. The film was part of the Melbourne Film Festival whose organisers refused to bow to pressure. Before the film was screened the festival website was hacked, though who was responsible is not known. The hackers displayed a Chinese flag and criticism of Rebiya on the website and were probably based in China. Here is the trailor to the film.

more about “THE 10 CONDITIONS OF LOVE“, posted with vodpod

Once upon a time the Chinese government just protested about the Dalai Lama or Kadeer visiting countries. Now it appears that any representation (or at least not state sanctioned) of the issues of either Tibetans or Uighurs is unacceptable and must be stopped. For now many countries resist the pressure from Beijing and its embassies, but this may not always be the case. Even heads of state in the UK, US and Germany, although meeting with the Dalai Lama, are careful to couch the visit in the right terms so not to anger Beijing too much. Is it too much to imagine sponsors, media groups and photo agencies be targeted in order to limit the dissemination of photos and films on these important issues and others the Chinese government would rather you do not see?

So, what is in these photo exhibitions or films that is so incendiary? I haven’t seen the photos in the Drik exhibition, and only the trailor for the film about Kadeer so I can not say for sure. You may be tempted to assume that they are controversial having caused so much fuss. However, from my experience of watching the Chinese censors at work and the government’s suppression of freedom of expression in China itself I would bet that these are less risky than the photos my friend took on his holiday to Bangkok when he was 18! I imagine they do not incite racial hatred or any such thing. The Chinese government needs to learn a thing or two about the use of images and their power. A revolution these will not make. A world wide movement these will not spawn. The attempt to ban such exhibitions and screenings will get them more attention and make more people aware of the situation of Uighurs and Tibetans inside and outside of China. In addition, the act of trying to ban these things in other countries, countries where freedom of express is highly valued, will only make people more likely to believe you are a big bully suppressing your ethnic minorities. This is a lose-lose strategy, believe me.

Of course the Chinese government is not alone in trying to censor or ban the showing of photos or films. It is just rather more unashamedly public and unapologetic about it. I guess that ‘non-interference’ thing means not only can you not tell them what to do at home but they can tell you what to think in yours.

Lessons to be learnt – Governments (at least some) are still very afraid of photos and films. Even if they are over reacting the fact they exaggerate their power is a bonus to activists using them. Fear will work against them and for us. So, the old tactic of exposing and witnessing is not dead yet.

Secondly, we have to expect more of this from China and other governments in the future. And we have to resist it, just as the guys at Drik did today. We have the tools now that make it nearly impossible for images and video to be suppressed. But the principle must be vocally defended too. The Chinese government can also be embarrassed, so remember to make some noise when they come sniffing round a photo exhibition or film festival near you.

Read more on what happened in the build-up to the exhibition at Drik here on Shaidul’s blog and here at Global Voices for a round-up of comment.

OSI ‘Moving Walls 16′ exhibition

moving walls 16_logo_OSI

More from the excellent multi-media and documentary photography work of the Open Society Institute. Whether you are a fan of Soros or not, OSI has invested heavily in the production of high quality visual products that are integrated into social justice campaigns.

moving wall 16_screen shot

The ‘Moving Walls 16‘ exhibition brings together work by six photographers. There is no common theme linking the work, though most focus on war or its aftermath.

The two that stand out for me are the work by Tomas van Houtryve covering the end of the CPN (Maoist) led ‘People’s War’ and Jana Andolan II that over threw the monarchical dictatorship of King Gyanendra in 2006 (though his work on the conflict started in 2004). Although the set presented here is slightly disjointed it gives a good snap shot of the transition from conflict to uneasy peace. This work is part of a larger projectComrade Revisited‘ documenting the world’s ‘last communist holdouts.’ It is worth checking out if only to see the full set of photos on Nepal.

The second stand out piece is by Paolo Woods entitled ‘Chinafrica‘ that looks at Chinese investment and economic migration to Africa. The images are stylised portraits that at times show an uneasy relationship between the Chinese migrants and the Africans they work with (or more accurately, work for them). Woods draws on European colonial imagery, though acknowledges that the Chinese presence in Africa is substantially different to that of the European colonialists.

paolo woods_moving walls_OSI

Copyright Paolo Woods

The Moving Walls 16 exhibition takes place at the OSI in New York from September 29 2009 to 21 May 2010.

Visualising China – 60 years of progress

Whilst on the visualisation theme here is one looking at progress in China over the last 60 years. Not convinced by the value of including mobile phone data considering they weren’t invented 60 yrs ago, but there you go.

now-44-China60th_1now-44-China60th_5now-44-China60th_4

now-44-China60th_3

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 658 other followers